I was reading Suicide by Emile Durkheim (this is a link to a summary); a 450 page behemoth with numbers and inferences about suicides. Durkheim’s work has been seminal to the understanding of suicide from a sociological perspective. Durkheim admits in the introduction to the book that attempting such a task such as recording suicide can be quite a challenge given how many deaths can escape this categorization.

I would think that if Durkheim was born in this age, he would be thoroughly pissed. Perhaps, with the rising world population, with more urbanization kicking in and larger sociological factors which could lead to suicide, documenting these facts would be quite a challenge today. The relative detachment from religious institutions which recorded such a data in the past would also be a contributing factor in making it more difficult to assess the numbers. On the other hand, would the state, which has taken over that responsibility (have they?), be recording such data? Or are we left to the mercy of randomized control trials?

I was just thinking about how with rising populations some things would become tougher to assess, no matter how improved the technology is. Not because the technology is lacking, but because contributing factors to a variety of events are coalescing and perhaps our technologies and data gathering techniques are just not able to match up to the speed with which our society and populations are changing.

 

Share

{ 0 comments }

A possible workout playlist?

by Rishabh on October 4, 2011 ·

in Ramblings


Yesterday I was asked to make a workout playlist, which is supposed to charge up one’s senses and make them jog their heart out. Of course there were some considerations that had to be taken into account.  Firstly, I don’t work out. So, at best, this list would be me indulging in wishful thinking. Secondly, I was given strict mandate that it should include various genres. But what it really means is that, it better have a fair amount of trance/dance stuff with a teeny weeny of other things. Thirdly, person summoning me is a woman.

With groggy eyes and little bit of reputation at stake, I embarked on the project. Here is the bastard child. Comments in brackets.

Modern Rock:

  • Joker and Thief – Wolfmother (Johnny Knoxville thinks its cool. So do I. But seriously speaking, right from the kick ass intro, the song is perfect for a morning jog)
  • Last Resort- Papa Roach (Old favorite from school days)

Classic Rock:

  • Start me up- Rolling Stone (It’s the frikkin Stones man)
  • Working Man- Rush

Hip Hop/Rap/Rap Rock:

  • American Boy- Kanye West
  • Ante Up- M.O.P (Probably one of the most thugged out songs ever, love the energy. Though, I will say this, this song is more likely to get you into a fight)
  • Remember the Name- Fort Minor (The NBA uses it, bitch!)
  • Numb/Encore – Jay Z/Linkin Park Low – Flo rida

Trance/Dance/Pop:

  • It ain’t gettin over- David Guetta, Fergie  (If you ask me, this is really a token Guetta song, for they all sound the same to me)
  • What is Love- Haddaway (I remember this song playing in most bowling alleys and arcades during the early 90s)
  • Pump It- Black Eyed Peas (Because it reminds me of Pulp Fiction. It probably will give you more of a heist feel than a workout)
  • Baya Baya – Safri Duo (With that kind of percussion, of course!)
  • I got a pocketful of Sunshine- Natasha Bedingfield
  • Bad Romance- Lady Gaga
  • Tik Tok- Kesha (what to say)

Notes: The last three are definitely very catchy, though I am kinda embarrassed they made it to the list. I would have liked a few RATMs in that list.

(Image courtesy: http://www.flickr.com/photos/jnforte/)

Share

{ 0 comments }

Art Appreciation (by Prof Anunaya Chaubey) is one of the courses that I am pursuing this term at the Young India Fellowship. One of the assignments is to visit the National Gallery of Modern Art, pick a painting and write about it, keeping in mind various criterion discussed in class.

I liked Satish Gujral’s Ecstasy, MF Husain’s Cyclonic Silence, an untitled work by SH Raza and a few other miniatures.

Upon returning to my hostel I thought these are big names, one could easily find their works online. Surely there must be scores of websites dedicated to their work.

How wrong I was.

Some of the foreign galleries have used technology and presented online viewers with a virtual tour of their paintings. Some other contemporary artists have their own websites showcasing their entire collection. The problem arises with artists, especially the Indian ones whose career span into decades. Websites are mostly maintained by fans, but there is again an inconsistency in the presentation, comprehensiveness or the regularity. And understandably so.

But I get a feeling that this must be the case with art in general. It is much easier to present music or text online. Paintings become a tough endeavor. The galleries don’t allow photography, and even if they are put up online, I am assuming the tagging done is so badly that it is virtually impossible to locate some of the earlier and relatively lesser known works online.

This however, might also be a worthy investment for a project. Perhaps by some like Soros’ Open Society Institute or perhaps Google itself. There should also be some crowdsourced medium where folks can upload the works of some of the great artists (to start with), so that there exist places, which aim to become the exhaustive catalog of these artists. And I think this is crucial especially from an Indian context.

 

Share

{ 0 comments }

Passing Opinions

by Rishabh on September 17, 2011 ·

in Uncategorized

Censure comes from Latin and means to pass an opinion or assess.

Film censorship becomes necessary because a film motivates thought and action and assures a high degree of attention and retention as compared to the printed word. The combination of act and speech, sight and sound in semi darkness of the theatre with elimination of all distracting ideas will have a strong impact on the minds of the viewers and can affect emotions. Therefore, it has as much potential for evil as it has for good and has an equal potential to instill or cultivate violent or good behaviour. It cannot be equated with other modes of communication. Censorship by prior restraint is, therefore, not only desirable but also necessary

Supreme Court of India

Why do you think we have so much vulgarity, songs, dances, pelvic thrusts, bathtub fantasies and dream sequences – because you won’t allow a simple kiss

Film maker Vijay Anand in an interview with India Today, 2002

I am currently reading The Republic by Plato, I am reminded of the noble lie that Socrates devises up to educate the republicans.

Share

{ 0 comments }

Term 2 has Media, Culture and Globalization being taught by Prof Radha Hegde. This obviously means that there’s a lot of reading to be done. There’s also a lot of watching that has to be done. This is the first course I have been a part of which showed an R Kelly video (Snake). The video was used to portray Orientalism. But I digress.

One of the course particulars includes us watching this video from Ghana where I suspect some NGOs Anya Kandel, founder of Momentus International (more about it here) and a graduate student at NYU, went around asking the kids about the questions they had for “The Man”. Here’s a video for your viewing pleasure:

 

Some questions are simple, such as why don’t the Heads of State fight wars themselves like duels of the past, as was the case during Aristocracy or why do Western nations come and work in Africa but make it tough for Africans to work there. Those are the hardest to answer. Then there were those which asked, why was it that in Africa they cane people. The answer to that I suppose could be because developed nations seem to have found an expensive alternative: suing.

One simple enough question on which I indeed had an opinion was when one boy asks whether there were mosquitoes in other countries, because here in Ghana, they bit them like crazy.

A simple check would tell you that Canada and US has anywhere between 400-2000 (?!) cases of Malaria each year, most of them attributed to immigrants from Asia and Sub saharan region. (Source). This is hardly surprising given the temperate regions that these nations lie in.

Jeffrey Sachs in End of Poverty and Commonwealth highlights how with the onset of rising temperatures, there are higher chances of US and other temperate regions facing a rise of malaria apart from a myriad of other diseases they’d have never experienced. As I have always maintained, while climate change will affect all of us (Remember in the long term, we’re all dead :) ), in the short term it will create winners and losers. Of course, with the rising temperatures, that’s going to be the least of their worries.

Update: After watching the video, we had a skype call with Anya to discuss her work and learning in Africa. Some interesting take aways from that:

1. The schools in South Ghana that Anya met had Muslim and Christian associations. Yet, when Anya asked them about a communal rift, they seemed puzzled. Anya shared that there was absolutely no communal issue, at least at the school level there.

2. The children were puzzled by the amount of waste that was being dumped into Africa by the developing nations. Having read a little about it earlier, I am aware that Africa is one of the largest dumping ground of electronic waste in the world.

3. Western nations have a intricate and violent history and there’s no escaping that. Any development work that takes place there needs to keep that in mind. At the same time, it’s also important to understand that Africa isn’t a homogeneous continent. Some nations have stable governments, some don’t. Some have done well for themselves as far as governance and economy goes (Rwanda for example under the leadership of Paul Kagame), some have well…not done so well.

It was nice chatting with Anya. She was quite patient with our questions and told us that she too was facing similar questions (Academia vs Corporate world/ notions of development/ impact vs approach ). Sort of tells us, despite the cultural differences, twenty somethings (or people in general) around the world have multiple strands connecting them.

Share

{ 1 comment }

Gandhi, Modernity, modernization

July 24, 2011

The 2nd semester at the YIF has a course called Gandhi’s critique of Modernity. This obviously means that there is tons of reading to be done. I thought of sharing some of the articles on this blog for benefit of others. “Gandhi After Gandhi After Gandhi” by Ashis Nandy. In the essay, Nandy speaks about [...]

Share
Read the full article →

Initial thoughts on Anish Kapoor’s Flesh

July 17, 2011

I had written a tiny piece for my writing class last week. The assignment was to take an art object and describe how we felt when we first saw it. To begin with I wrote about an Air Conditioner. After further discussions, I decided to write about another art object, this one more mainstream as [...]

Share
Read the full article →

Will all your base are belong to us?

July 5, 2011

A few days ago I wrote an essay as part of the writing class at the Young India Fellowship. The essay demanded that we take the central idea from one of the essays discussed in class, and use that to write about a personal experience referencing 2 other essays (including the one from which the [...]

Share
Read the full article →

An audio mode for Youtube?

June 24, 2011

Why doesn’t Youtube have an audio mode? The wi-fi connection that we seemed to have in our hostel is not very reliable with speeds. And I have this habit of treating Youtube like a media player where I let the songs in my playlist go on. Possibly because Youtube is by far the largest repository [...]

Share
Read the full article →

3 days with Sanjeev Aga

June 20, 2011

As part of the Young India Fellowship program, we spent the weekend in Sanjeev Aga’s company who recently stepped down as the MD of Idea Cellular (complete bio here). The session was a narrative. A rather long one. And that was the best part. I missed Day 1, but was keenly paying attention to every [...]

Share
Read the full article →